Mary
1,237 reviews12 followers
I had to skim through the last several chapters because I found this account of Smith's life to be so painful. Her childhood as recounted in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn we know was difficult but so were her marriages and her last days on earth. Yow has written a powerful book about an amazing woman.
- biography
Sherri
Author2 books
Betty Smith's life makes Francie's look like a day in the park. The thing I loved most about "A Tree Grows in Brooklyn" and "Joy in the Morning" was the feeling of hope and the resiliency of the characters. Betty perserveres and is highly successful in her career but her personal life is tragic. Healthy interpersonal relationships elude her. I finally gave up on the book to turn to something more cheerful (Lord of the Flies is more cheerful).
I realize not liking a biography because the subjects story isn't fun is a pretty shallow critique. The book is well written, the subject ceased to be compelling for me. It may not be so for you.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Molly
333 reviews7 followers
The only biography of Betty Smith that has crossed my path. Well worth reading for Betty Smith fans.
- read-in-2012
Melissa Mannon
Author7 books8 followers
I enjoyed reading about the author of my favorite book. "Betty Smith: The Life of the Author of 'A Tree Grows in Brooklyn'" is insightful, but suffers a bit from too much unnecessary detail. References to letters that tell something about the author's relationships often give little insight into her character. Their inclusion makes some of the writing seem stilted, highlighting gaps in documentation about Smith more than enlightening us. The author of the biography, Valerie Raleigh Yow shines in her analysis of Betty Smith's books. When she doesn't quote archival material directly, she also does a good job explaining Smith's relationships and how they influenced her writing. I now look forward to reading the books written by Smith that I haven't yet read. I had no idea she was such a prolific author and sage mentor, nor did I realize her status as a playwright.
- biography strong-female
Peg
763 reviews6 followers
Chapel Hill, NC writer Valerie Yow author of biography of Betty Smith speaking locally (i.e Carolina Meadows Tues 4/22 at 2 p.m. Betty Smith and her two daughters came to Chapel Hill in 1936, after Smith convinced playwright Paul Green and Drama Department chairman Frederick Koch to lobby on her behalf for one of 4 Federal Theater Project positions at UNC. She lived in Chapel Hill from then on. .. first at a rental house 504 North St, where she wrote " A Tree Grows in Brooklyn." Profits from that ovel enabled Smith to purchase a home at 315 East Rosemary Street.
Tamhack
285 reviews9 followers
This is the biography of the Author of "A Tree Grows in Brooklyn". Betty says that the character Francie is herself and her other relatives were inspirations for the characters in the book. At 16, Betty started working in NY and could afford to go to Broadway shows. Her reading and watching plays helped to write dialogues, plays, and her books. She wrote several other books besides "A Tree Grows in Brooklyn". She cared deeply for writing, her children and grandchildren and gardening. She was very good at illustrated the ordinary life of people in a very revealing way.
Starburst
202 reviews6 followers
Very good! I appreciate how the author draws shows the clear parallels between Betty Smith's life and the life of the characters in her books. Unlike many biographies, it doesn't get boring in the middle, which I appreciate. I don't know how I feel about the impression I got of Betty Smith herself... she certainly was a complicated person but also left us with great works.
Lee Anne
856 reviews85 followers
Since I didn’t really know anything about Betty Smith, this well-researched biography was exactly what I wanted. Halfway through, I texted a friend and fellow With the exception of Betty Smith’s multiple marriages, I found her life comparable in some ways to that of a couple of my other favorite mid-century women authors: Shirley Jackson and Betty MacDonald. Here are three women who are driven to write, but also neurotic, and find their day-to-day life split almost evenly between that mad impulse to put pen to paper (or keys to typewriter) and the demands of domestic life—children, family, homeownership. It’s hard not to romanticize that role of the brilliant housewife author, cigarette in hand, rolled up dungarees or maybe an old shirt dress and cardigan combo, shooing the kids out of the writing room in the morning, then painting the spare bedroom or planting some tulip bulbs in the afternoon. Sigh.
Carol
19 reviews2 followers
If you read Betty Smith’s four books, especially A Tree Grows In Brooklyn, this book of Betty Smith’s life will interest you. It is very detailed of her life, family, friends and writing career.
Joanne
672 reviews6 followers
This book gets pretty bogged down in unnecessary details. While Betty led quite a life, I would recommend A Tree Grows in Brooklyn instead.
Barbara Allen
Author3 books25 followers
This is a great biography, one of the best I have ever read.
Adele Goetz
289 reviews
"A Tree Grows in Brooklyn" is one of my top books of all time - I could read it over and over, so it was somewhat interesting to see how much of the book is based on the author's life. That said, this book was well-researched, but is not exactly a page-turner.
Kysha
6 reviews
I loved this book!
Dawn
2 reviews
This was my favorite book in high school.
Pinkhouse
3 reviews1 follower
everyone should read this beautiful book
Megan
69 reviews
Absolutely fascinating final piece after reading all of her novels, this biography tied everything together.
Audra Korenak
11 reviews
I love love love this book, it is a close second behing To Kill a Mockingbird on my list of favorites
Millie
9 reviews
a great book noting the coming of age.
Eileen Gale Kugler
15 reviews6 followers
I love books that give you insights into cultures and experiences. She paints a picture of early immigrant life in NYC at beginning of 20th century. Characters jump off the page
Lani
19 reviews
Read
October 20, 2009Wanted to learn more about the author of A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and Joy in the Morning. Interesting read since both books were semi-autobiographical.
Joan Foss
117 reviews
Book group choice, then I never got to the discussion! A favorite of mine, and in my opinion a classic.